Answers and mentions produce different denominators
Peec's documentation defines visibility as the percentage of responses mentioning a brand. Its share-of-voice documentation instead divides the brand's mentions by total brand mentions and describes comparison with tracked competitors. Those are different units. The wording alone does not settle every counting detail, such as how repeated names within one answer are handled. Peec visibility, Peec share of voice
Profound's Reports v2 documentation also separates visibility, share of voice and average position. It describes visibility as the share of answers containing the asset, share of voice as the share of all mentions, and position as the average rank when mentioned. The documented grouping options include model, prompt and region. The navigation labels these v2 reports Beta; documentation is not proof of an entitlement in a particular subscription. Profound Visibility v2
These definitions establish what to investigate. They do not establish that two products use identical brand matching, sampling, repetition or exclusion rules.
Follow the arithmetic through one fictional ledger
Suppose a saved set contains 10 completed answers. Your brand appears in 3 of them. An analyst records 5 mentions of your brand and 25 mentions across the selected brands, counting repeated mentions in this particular example.
Scroll horizontally to read all columns. Use the arrow keys when the table is focused.
| Calculation | Numerator | Denominator | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Share of answers naming your brand | 3 answers | 10 completed answers | 30% |
| Share of recorded brand mentions | 5 mentions | 25 recorded mentions | 20% |
Both calculations can be correct. Neither percentage states that the brand was recommended, that its website was cited or that anyone visited the site. Those require separate evidence from the answer, links or analytics.
Original arithmetic example, not a vendor result. Ten completed answers contain three answers naming the brand, five recorded mentions of that brand and 25 recorded mentions in total. Repeated mentions count in this illustration; a vendor's rule must be verified separately.
Now keep every answer unchanged but include another competitor's 10 recorded mentions in the comparison. The brand still appears in 3 of 10 answers, so answer presence stays 30%. Its mention share becomes 5 of 35, about 14.3%. The changed comparison population explains that decline; the example contains no change in the underlying answers.
This is a reason to preserve the competitor set alongside a chart. It is not a claim that adding a competitor triggers that exact behavior in either product.
Require enough detail to reproduce the displayed result
Use a saved result from the vendor's demonstration to work through these questions. A blank field should remain an unresolved evaluation item rather than become an assumed capability.
Scroll horizontally to read all columns. Use the arrow keys when the table is focused.
| What to establish | Evidence to request |
|---|---|
| Eligible population | Exact questions, engine or product surface, collection dates, region and included answer IDs |
| Counting unit | Once per answer, each occurrence, named recommendation, citation or another documented event |
| Entity matching | The names and aliases included, with ambiguous matches available for review |
| Failure handling | Attempted, completed, unavailable and valid-empty records shown separately |
| Weighting | Whether each answer, question or engine contributes equally, and how missing records are handled |
| Comparison population | Which competitors are included and whether changing that set recalculates historical figures |
For example, if one question has many more completed answers than another, pooling every answer gives the heavily sampled question more influence. An average of question-level percentages can answer a different question. Ask the vendor to show the calculation it uses rather than select whichever method produces the preferred score.
A collection failure is also different from a completed answer that does not name the brand. If a provider was unavailable, counting that attempt as a negative mention result would change the meaning of the percentage. Record the missing coverage explicitly before drawing a comparison.
Choose a score you can explain to someone else
At the end of the demonstration, write one sentence using the underlying unit: for example, “The brand appeared in 3 of these 10 completed answers.” Then add the engine, dates and question set from the actual report. If the sentence cannot be completed from available evidence, retain that gap in the buying decision.
A tool's value can include convenience, workflow and coverage. A larger percentage by itself is not evidence of better measurement. Once the population and counting rules are clear, the team can use the existing weekly-report guide to report changes without silently changing what the number means.
Sources and scope
Gist publishes this guide and sells AI visibility software. The evaluation criteria apply equally to Gist and other vendors. Public documentation was checked November 18, 2026. We did not test vendor accounts or compare product accuracy, prices or commercial entitlements. The arithmetic and evaluation worksheet are original examples, not collected AI answers.